Carmen Winstead

The story of Carmen Winstead is an urban legend about a 17-year old girl who was pushed down a sewer opening by five girls she thought were her friends. The chain letter claims that a boy named David Gregory died when he didn’t pass it on.

Carmen Winstead

Carmen Winstead was 17 years old when her parents decided to move to Indiana. Her father had lost his job and the only way he could find new employment was by moving to a new state. The relocation caused a lot of problems for Carmen. She had to leave her friends behind and attend a whole new school in Indiana.

Carmen had a hard time making friends when she changed schools. It was the middle of the school year and most of the students had no interest in befriending the new girl. Initially, she spent many days alone, walking from class to class without speaking to anyone, but she eventually started hanging around with a group of five other girls. Carmen thought these girls were her friends, but it wasn’t long before she discovered that they had been talking about her behind her back and spreading vile rumors.

When she confronted them, the girls turned on her and began bullying her every day, making her life a misery. They started out calling her names, but then the bullying got much worse. One day, she left her school books in the classroom at break time. When she returned, she found someone had taken a sharpie and written dirty words all over her books. Another day, she opened her bag and discovered someone had poured yoghurt all over the insides. Sometimes, she would come to school and find her locker had been vandalized. The final straw came when she put on her coat at recess and found that someone had stuffed dog poop in her pockets.

There and then, Carmen decided that she couldn’t take the bullying any longer. She planned to stay behind, that evening, after school, and tell her teacher what had been happening. Unfortunately, her decision came too late to save her life.

After lunch, her teacher announced that the school was holding a fire drill. When the alarm sounded, Carmen and the other students filed out of the classroom and assembled in the yard outside. As the teachers read out the roll call, the gang of five girls decided that this was a great opportunity to embarrass Carmen in front of the whole school during the fire drill. They moved over to where Carmen was standing, near a sewer drain, and began crowding the poor girl, getting in her face and nudging her towards the open manhole.

They pushed her and she tripped over and fell head-first down the manhole. When they saw her falling, the girls started giggling and when Carmen’s name was called out, they shouted “She’s down in the sewer!”

All of the other students began laughing. But when the teachers looked down the manhole and saw Carmen’s body lying at the bottom in the muck and the poop, the laughter abruptly stopped. Her head was twisted around at an odd angle and her face was covered in blood. Worse still, she wasn’t moving.

There was nothing any of the teachers could do for her. Carmen was dead. When the police arrived and went down into the sewer, they determined that she had broken her neck. Her face had been torn off when she hit the ladder on the way down and her neck snapped when she landed on her head on the concrete at the bottom.

The police hauled Carmen’s body out of the sewer and sent her to the mortuary. Everyone had to stay behind after school while the police questioned all of Carmen’s classmates. The five girls lied to the police, saying they had witnessed Carmen falling down the sewer. The police believed the girls and Carmen Winstead’s death was ruled an accident and the case was closed. Everyone thought that was the last they would hear of Carmen Winstead, but they were wrong.

Months later, Carmen’s classmates began receiving strange e-mails on their MySpaces. The e-mails were titled “They Pushed Her” and claimed that Carmen hadn’t really fallen down the sewer, she had been pushed. The e-mails also warned that the guilty people should own up and take responsibility for their crime. If they didn’t there would be horrible consequences. Most people dismissed the e-mails as a hoax, but others were not so sure.

A few days later, one of the girls who pushed Carmen down the sewer was at home taking a shower, when she heard a strange cackling laugh. It seemed to be coming from the drain. The girl started to freak out and ran out of the bathroom. That night, the girl said goodnight to her mom and went to sleep.

Five hours later, her mom was awoken in the middle of the night, by a loud noise that resounded throughout the house. She ran into her daughter’s room, only to find it empty. There was no trace of the girl. The worried mother called the police and when they arrived, they conducted a search of the area. Eventually, they discovered the girl’s grisly remains.

Her corpse was lying in the sewer, covered in muck and poop. Her neck was broken and her face was missing. It had been completely torn off. One by one, all of the girls who pushed Carmen that day were found dead. They had all been killed in exactly the same way and were all found at exactly the same spot. In the sewer at the bottom of the same uncovered manhole where Carmen had met her doom.

But the killing didn’t stop there. More and more of Carmen’s former classmates were found dead. It seemed that anyone who didn’t believe that Carmen had been pushed, was eventually found down in the sewer with their necks broken and their faces torn off.

They say that Carmen’s ghost is still on the rampage, hunting down anyone who doesn’t believe her story. According to the legend, Carmen will get you, whether it’s from a toilet, a shower, a sink or a drain. When you go to sleep, youโ€™ll wake up in the sewer, in complete darkness, paralyzed, unable to move, hearing cackling laughter all around you. Then, as you scream in horror, Carmen will come and tear your face off.

So be careful who you bully, because you just might find yourself on the receiving end of the curse of Carmen Winstead.

(To show Carmen you support her and are against bullying, share the link to this story with your friends on Twitter, Facebook, Google+, etc…)

Comments

  1. Tewwowistreads says

    How could the girls be so mean??? They got what they deserved and i totally believe this was real that the five girls pushed her into the manhole.

  2. ItzyahgirlJules says

    To everyone who thinks its fake, It’s REAL! Me and my bestie were walking home and I didn’t send it. Immediately a sainsbury lorry came charging for me and I quick ran out of there. I got home and sent it to everyone, Even taking my old phone to make a new whatsapp account to send to.

  3. randi_2002 says

    CARMEN I’m so sorry those girls did that to you I believe your story and I will never forget you will always be on my mind CARMEN WINDSTEADโค๏ธ๐Ÿ’™๐Ÿ’›๐Ÿ’œ๐Ÿ’šโฃ๏ธ๐Ÿ’“๐Ÿ’•๐Ÿ’—๐Ÿ’ž๐Ÿ’–๐Ÿ’๐Ÿ’˜

  4. alesha says

    Omg. I feel so sorry for you๐Ÿ˜” I really do believe this. I actually cried for ages while reading this. You sound like such a nice person. I would of loved to be friends. I have a feeling that be would be best friends. R.I.Pโค๏ธ๐Ÿ’›๐Ÿ’š๐Ÿ’™๐Ÿ’œ

  5. hoho says

    Its a sad story. Bullying is always wrong, i am always on your side Carmen Winston i just dont have 15 People to send it to but no worries. Im Always On Your Side Carmen Winston! :)

  6. LightBulbInspiration says

    Dang. Those girls were so cruel. How could they do such a thing. I shared it with almost everyone in my contacts (about 30). Pls don’t kill me!!! ;) I’m always on you’re side Carmen. ;)

  7. maddiemc2003 says

    Im not sure if i believe what happend to carmen but i definitly dont believe what happend to the 5 girls who pushed carmen. Even though i dont believe this i think it sets a good example of what can happen if you take bullying to a whole new level. โค๏ธ

  8. kat says

    Im soooo sorry about what happened to you Carmen! โค Bullies are mean and what happened to you was not deserved. I shared this on instagram and i hope that all my followers will share and consider what happened to you. Please dont kill me. I hope that this is enough ๐Ÿ˜ R.I.P.โคโคโคโค

  9. amelia_alexandra108 says

    This is so sad Carmen I am so sorry for ur own lost. Those girls had no right to do that to u. If anybody ever bullied me I would probally ignore it just like u. But once I got bullied so bad that I almost broke my ankle. That’s when I had to tell the teacher. My story is nothing like yours. Yours is way more serious. But let me just say again those girls had NO absolute right to do that to you. I am hoping u have a great life in heaven and I absolutely believe ur story ๐Ÿ˜˜๐Ÿ˜˜

  10. msilva says

    Carmin I beliveve ur story I just don’t have 15 people to send it to because I have no friends. But bullying always goes to far it really needs to stop but most people bully because they have a tough life or they are jealous of you

  11. Llama_Loverโค๏ธ๐Ÿ• says

    Dear Ms.Carmen Winstead,
    I believe your story. Those girls had no right to bully you. I can’t share your story but all I can say is sorry. I hope this is enough. My friends believe you and so do I. May you rest in peace. Please don’t kill me!
    – Ali H

  12. DiabeticABCs says

    So, people still believe in this Carmen bullshit, still? Do some research, it’s FAKE! The story is just basically made up by girls in Myspace! I have to admit I sound like a ratchet meanie bitch but go GOOGLE IT people. Internet exists for a reason.

  13. TwilightKitten99 says

    I remember this so clearly! There was a incident involving Carmen Winstead at my school last year.
    It’s not a true story, but I think this is a good example of when bullying goes too far!

  14. Iroberts220044 says

    I totally believe this I feel really bad for her! She shouldn’t have got bullied! Bullies all of the time are really the ones who are mean and awful and they really do not deserve to get treated the way they do!

  15. geegee2 says

    This Is dreadful, makes me so angry to know that sick girls can treat Carmen like that makes me sick, I love you carmen I bet your the best Angel in the sky๐Ÿ˜

  16. She Devil666 says

    Aw!! Poor Carmen! She didn’t deserve that! Me and my friends at school, we find it so sad what happened to Carmen! โค๏ธ๐Ÿ˜ญ

  17. Firefoxx says

    I honestly believe this. I have been excluded before, and I know how it feels. Those girls were low, and pushing Carmen down the sewer wasn’t a prank, it was downright evil. How does anyone think that pushing someone into a sewer is “just a prank”? They could get seriously injured, or even worse, like Carmen’s case, die. Safety Kitty and Kawaii Ghost will protect everyone. :)

  18. xXHERRAARRXx says

    @ SFK, I wanted to share this, but I copy and paste it ๐Ÿ˜ฃ

    Scaryforkids says: Oops… Next time you take a shower, stay away from the drain… :P

  19. jckthekid248 says

    if I was in that school I would have talked to her and became friends with her I don’t care if people said why you talking to her she ugly she has no friends I was a bully to someone his name was David but we made up and a few days ago after I did that I never want to do that ever to anyone again after I saw your story and I send it to 15 people like it said make sure those girls rot in hell of what they did to you.

  20. zec2001 says

    Carmen shouldn’t of been bullied by these girls and I hope she will get her revenge and then rest in peace. #iknowhowufillcarmen

  21. victoriadreams104481 says

    Man I’ve sent this to 17 people and most of them replied with this is dumb but I didn’t, bullying is wrong and I get bullyed because I’m tall I’m in 8th grade and I am 5″11 and everyone calls me the green giant I know how you feel babe I hope you rest in peace and I hope those girls got what they deserved ๐Ÿ’–

  22. xXHERRAARRXx says

    Ok, when I heard this was the most popular story, I didn’t expect it to be this popular!!!!!!

  23. Creppylittlegeek says

    Aw..R.I.P Carmen, you seemed like a nice girl, I would be friends with you if we knew each other <3 I believe in this story and i hope you finally find peace

  24. Gabe13 says

    Carmen, i feel changed your story inspired me completely , you are such a sweetheart, those horrible girl deserve what they got bullying such a nice person like yourself im hear for you, the world is so cruel,you were so young like myself, i was bullied quite a bit, but after reading your story i 100% believe it all , your such a talented young girl with plans those gastly girl ruined everthing, all the people who bullied you deserved it, all of it R.I.P Carmen Winstead.

  25. linadianaa says

    I really hope you find your peace,Carmen ! We should never bully a person. I’m really sorry for what they did to you !

  26. bella.nicoletta says

    Hello it’s me…. Get it Adele!!! Ok nvm I also believe this 100% and someone so innocent beautiful talented and inspirational should not deserve such cruel punishment!! Those girls truly deserved it for what they did. May you rest in peace and stay beautiful ๐Ÿ˜˜โฌ‡๏ธโฌ‡๏ธโฌ‡๏ธโฌ‡๏ธ

  27. bella.nicoletta says

    Dear Carmen…..
    I inspire you and think those mean girls deserve what you did to them. I am only young and honestly don’t think I need to die yet. You shouldn’t have either…. You were so young. I know God had a plan for you and those stupid girls foiled it๐Ÿ˜ก Please don’t hurt me. You inspire me to let me people know about you. Please spare my life and friends and family๐Ÿ˜‡I admire your work๐Ÿ˜ƒI know you were innocent and if you could protect me like that girl Charlotte I would greatly appreciate it….. Thank you for listening to me ๐Ÿ˜˜โค๏ธ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿป
    Love Isabella Leal, Parker Leal and our friends and family โค๏ธ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿป๐Ÿ˜˜

  28. Ummmthatsmoe says

    Carmen Winston I believe your story.My friend sent me a link and I totally freaked out cause I’m thinking why would he send me this so I listen to it and I cried why would them mean girls do such a horrible thing so I research your story and I believe all of it R.I.P Carmen you were so beautiful really and I would have loved to meet you in person but your story will live on trust mne you won’t be forgotten

  29. Ayee_Its_Lucy says

    Carmen, I believe your story. Who would make something like that up? I honestly think you and me could have been good friends. I’m mature for a 12 year old. I was disgusted when I heard what those girls did to you. It made me wanna vomit. And not even admitting to killing someone? Even worse. You can admit to that, though. Because those girls deserved it. You might not like me, but after hearing your story, I’d like to meet you. It’s a shame that we couldn’t have met. I would have stood up for, risked my life for you even. I am so sorry that some people are vile. I actually want to cry right now. I got your voice message and immediately forwarded it to 25 friends. That’s how much I believe. And I am praying that soon enough, your soul will descend to Heaven, if you already haven’t. You’re forever in my prayers.

    ~Lucy Jayne

  30. reklats says

    david gregory is real google search him now right now NON Belivers belive it because david gregory is david gregory is is is real he is REAL google search david gregory chain letter it will tell you all you need you are meant to post carmen winstead with the title “they hurt her” or “they pushed her” do it for your saftey sfk fans do it do it do it do it do it do it

  31. 11702Horse says

    I believe in you Carmen. I was bullied too and I think it should be stopped. I wish I could’ve met you Carmen, you seem pretty cool.

  32. belive21 says

    I’ve been bullied heaps and it’s not nice. I believe in you carmen and I feel sorry for you.๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ฅ๐Ÿ˜ข๐Ÿ˜ช๐Ÿ˜ญ

  33. celena_brown says

    I believe in you Carmen and I’m on your side I understand how you feel because I was bullied to. And I’m so sorry that happened to you what they did was wrong. The world is so mean. I hope you can find peace and happiness

  34. tabathaelliott says

    Carmen I believe your story and those girl deserve wat they that got being so rude to u ! Being so mean does mean you have to kill of lie and just don’t be mean its not that easy to be nice to someone in all hands I believe everything carmen everything

  35. Scary.cruel.sad says

    I believe you carmen, your story is terrible those bullys are mean, thankyou you have opened my eyes to life, no one should be treated wrong whether it be religion, sexuality,weight,culture/race,
    Speech or even being different
    I feel for you there are loads of bullys in life and its not fair a teacher can be a bully a friend boss landlord or others this shouldnt happen im very sorry carmen, may you rest in piece๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ข๐Ÿ˜ฆ๐Ÿ˜ญ
    From scary.cruel.sad

  36. metalrock-lover says

    I feel so bad for Carmen๐Ÿ˜ข I was bullied too, and I couldn’t take it so i attempted suicide.

    I’m so sorry princessโค I hope you meet my dad up there sweet angel xx

    I bet you were talented and amazingโค

    What they did was hiddious. They’re true monsters.

    I love you sweet princessโค I wish I could of met you xx

    R.I.P

  37. casscass13 says

    Carmen we all believe your story is true!! We are so sorry for what happened!! May you rest in peace! Love Cassidy, Daisie, Shannon, Darcie, Maisie, Izzy,
    Luis and Eva๐Ÿ‘ผ๐Ÿผ๐Ÿ’—Xxx

  38. The Light of Lilly says

    Great story about bullying. Poor Carmen, she did not have a chance to do anything with her life, only in death she can make people think twice before being bullies. R.I.P. dear Carmen, you did not deserve that treatment and bullying from those girls.

    – Never bully, it is ignorent and completely unacceptable.

  39. Gymnast1072 says

    That’s so sad. Carmen, if I were there, that would not have happened. I’m so sorry that that happened to you. RIP, Carmen. And I completely understand why you would be so mad at the world, I would be, too. Those girls went WAY too far. RIP, girl. See you in Heaven!โค๏ธ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿป๐Ÿ‘ผ๐Ÿป๐Ÿ˜‡

  40. vtbear says

    OMG I totally believe this is 100% true. That was so mean if them to push you. I would never be that mean to a new kid. I feel so bad because you never deserved to be treated that way and I totally would have stuck up for u if I was there to see it, I would also kick those girl’s butts and anyone else who didn’t believe you. I feel so sorry and RIP because you deserve to rest in the best place on earth๐Ÿ˜Š๐Ÿ™๐Ÿผ

  41. lilbrat80 says

    Carmen i would have yo back i would be there for u u could be with me F them haters i would protect you…i hope u rest in peace… at least u got revenge on them they only did that to u bc they were jealous bc u were probably prettier well we all love u ik i do an i hope u are doing good if they were still here i would beat them up for doing that to u! Love u forever an always ๐Ÿ˜˜๐Ÿ˜™๐Ÿ˜

  42. LoveStar says

    I am so sorry Carmen. I know how you feel. I got bullied to and you didn’t deserve any of that. Rest in Peace. Those girls got what they deserved. I believe your story 100%.

  43. DerekCulp says

    Carmen i am soo sorry for you. Those girls if i would have knew they were going to do that i would have killed them before they could have done anything too you. Carmen we all can say we love you and Rest in Peace Carmen. I get bullied at school too soo i can feel the way u do when u were getting bullied. R.I.P Carmen

  44. pizzalover12 says

    bullying is so not funny at all. the people that gotten bullied it is not fair to us that we get bullied i believe it sounds true and why carmen trip herself down a sewr she deserved a life and thos girls didnt diserve anything except punisment i hope carmen winstead rip and one day will happy. thos people who didnjt believe this and trashed on it and told that the story and sheshould of burned that is not cool that will reflect off of u. I think that she is real even thoygh this may be a urben legened i still believen stuff like this she shouldnt have died. And if this story is real dont worry many of my frtiends have gotten bullied before i try to cher them up and it works. Cause of bullying many boys and girls have kiiled them self or have gotten deeply hurted. I AM AGAINST BULLING AND SHOULD BE TO

  45. om101 says

    This is so upsetting for something like this to happen to Carmen! I feel her pain I’m being bullied! Everywhere I look people get bullied. I’m on our side Carmen! These 5 ‘friends’ of yours deserved it has a punishment! Hang in their Carmen!!

  46. Spaghetti Senpai says

    Carmen didn’t deserve to be treated like that. Even if this is real or not, no one deserves to be treated like that. I hope Carmen can rest peacefully and happily one day.

  47. missnan says

    i am totaly agianst bulliying and i fell so sorry for carmon she didnt deserve to did those girls do! i would have been her friend

  48. kitkat says

    This is true believe me i had my friend witness it or she told me that it is true i’m so scared i fell really bad fro Carmen i’m so sorry Carmen i believe in you i am against bullying and want the people to stop.

  49. DeadlyDancer says

    Omg I m about TO TAKE A SHOWER ยกยก !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ยง. ยฅ@ยงยป7โ€ฆ,ยฟ. ยฟโ€ข โ€”โ€“:;()โ‚ฌยฅโ‚ฝยขยฃโ‚ฉโ€žยซโ€โ€œโ€žยกโ€™c[]{}#%โ€ฐ^*+=โ€ขยฃยฅโ‚ฌ><~|\_.,โ€ฆยฟยก'

  50. Chosen1 says

    Honestly guys… This is fake… I mean come on!! I didn’t even believe in this! Now look who’s alive? (Unless theres a spirit typing… Then its true…)

  51. alexis123m says

    That’s Scary but that’s okay because I like that! I have recieved messages and voice messages in Carmens voice saying if I don’t send it to 15 people I will die the same way she did! I didn’t share! Look here I’m still alive! I believe it though because it’s so interesting

  52. FAN OF SCARY FOR KIDS says

    This is a very famous legend! The pic is super creepy! I hate bullying! And i also hate the people who bully! I wish every bulliers can experience the same fate! Then there would be no crime in this world!

  53. SYNERGYIAN says

    They Should’nt Have Done It. R.I.P Carmen. Pls Don’t Hurt Me Or My Family,We are against bullying. I Too am like you but i didn’t die because of being bullied.Carmen We All Are With You.

  54. Horrorstar says

    Why was my comment removed? Because they thought that i was joking?NO JOKE NO!!!! I really really really saw that upsetting dream, it made my head spin. Why dont u believe me, SFK??

  55. kyrah300 says

    I’m so Sorry Carmen. My mom said it was fake but Please Don’t Kill Her. Those girls are rude. My friend sent it to me but please please don’t hurt my family or me. Thank you. R.I.P Carmen Winstead

  56. klsluciano says

    I have 0 doubt that the girl was pushed. Kids will do anything to humiliate another classmate. However does it say that you have to believe that she is a ghost killing people? I believe in ghosts and all but I never really thought that they could physically interact with a human. The only spirit that could do that would be a demon. So as a conspiracy theory, this story could be very much true except that the ghost wouldn’t be Carmen herself but a demon of that form.

  57. Maddiee says

    This is SO terrible,I wish she was still alive.those girls are dead cuz they could of done it AGAIN!!! I really believe her because why would she be so clumsy!!!she sound really smart.
    R.I.P Carmen

  58. scarrygurl500 says

    So sorry about what happened to you Carmen please don’t come and kill me but you can come and talk to me any time I know how it feels to be bullied and I can talk to ghosts so mabey me and you could talk it out Carmen so don’t kill me but you can talk to me.

  59. snowwhite says

    I believe Carmen,and i know lots of innocent boys and girls have died because of bulling and ragging this is so not fair…

  60. kirstij says

    Carmen I am so sorry about what those girls did to you. & I do 100% percent believe in you’re story. Those girls were very mean to you & they should not have done what they have done! Please do not kill me I am only 14 I have my whole life ahead of me!

  61. ifeelawfulforu says

    Dear Carmen, That’s so awful! I mean who would push a innocent girl like you Carmen down a sewer! You did the right thing Carmen! Give those girls what they deserve! Apparently, you did. Anyways, I hope you see this in heaven because I believe you! I am always on your side, I have been bullied at school so I know how it feels. Don’t worry Carmen, people like us will succeed one day!

  62. annalovesharry22 says

    I’m so sorry! That should have never happened to you! I’m sure you were a great girl. Rip.

  63. shdjbwna says

    I’m not gonna lie and say you are a great person because I have no idea whether u r or not. What I am gonna say is that you are incredibly brave and those other girls are terrible people. I’m so sorry, RIP

  64. Renegade says

    Carmen I know what’s it’s like to have cruel people who you thought were friends I hope you found peace R.I.P Carmen

  65. imsosorrycarmen says

    I’m so, so sorry Carmen. I feel awful. Those kids where absolutely terrible, for in so many ways. I hope you rest in peace, whatever sort of after life there is. I’m glad those awful girls got what they deserved. And I’m so, so sorry.

  66. UrbanJustice says

    Bullying is so wrong. Poor Carmen. I bet she was so sweet. Those girls got what they deserved. I love you, Carmen and I would have saved you if I was there at the time. May your soul R.I.P. I believe 100% that she was murdered. I believe it was no accident. I shared this on Facebook as well.

  67. killer44 says

    Carmen I believe this and I hope you find peace and I bet those girl got what they deserve and R.I.P carmen

  68. kristasomerss says

    i believe this story, carmen those girls had no right to do that bc after reading this i think you are a nice girl before you died, rip

  69. Eaglefire says

    I believe you 100% and I even shared your story on Facebook. I know how you felt I get bullied everyday, by family and other kids. I have also had some girls at school who I thought were my friends who have turned against me. I feel so bad about how bad it was for you.

  70. peter says

    i believe your story carmen winstead your so beautiful at your teens im against bullying and against making fun of people also i believe your story when you got push down the sewer by five girls that was bullies and im so sorry for what happen to you and i know its tough for you to have a unpleasant day at school.

  71. Izzy says

    I believe in this and I posted it on Instagram and if I was with you I would be Besties with you for life Carmen I really miss you and wish you were still with us and them girls should be punished

  72. Rebekah219 says

    I believe Carmen was pushed. It seems like something those girls would do. All my life I’ve been bullied at school and abused at home. Why, just last year I thought I could trust these two girls, but then they beat me up at a sleepover. They would have killed me if I didn’t go home. Sorry Carmen.

  73. kacee_dadancer says

    On your side it is so sad what happened I would never do that sad what happed ๐Ÿ˜ช๐Ÿ˜”

  74. stephanie2014 says

    Carmen I’m on your side I would never bully someone . I care for you and my friend. I would be nice and kind to you and be your Best friend forever. Love you Carmen, rest in peace. ๐ŸŒŒ๐ŸŒŒ๐ŸŒŒ๐ŸŒŒ

  75. avaotto1 says

    on your side carmen I’m ava and hope you find peace and those girl commit suicide

  76. midnightroses says

    Doesn’t everyone knows this is fake? Chain letters are fake (no ghost can get you) and the Carmen Winstead thing never happened.

  77. shivereen2003 says

    Hi Carmen, I am Samidha. I hate such bullies and i am 100 percent on Your side. I hope u find peace soon. Sorry

  78. geckoindawada says

    i have been bullied. i know what its like to be alone. they pushed you and they went to far. i am sorry carmen, you derserved better then this. you should have been treated fairly, and loved. you were strong brave sweet and kind. and they got to suffer the same pain as you, and they deserved every minuet of it. also please pardon my bad spelling this was also some thing i was bullied about. thank you and rest in peace

  79. nerdyrobdob says

    Carmen they deserved what they got you are beautiful no one should ever be bullied I believe in you and we could have been really great friends love you ๐Ÿ˜˜

  80. TigerTori says

    Tbh..I think that those girls got what they deserved. Carmen do isn’t deserve any of that. All she was trying to do was make friends.

  81. Ifeelsorryforu says

    R.I.P Carmen, I hope you find peace one day. I believe your story 100%
    Those girls better get what they deserve because I don’t think it’s fair that they do that to someone as lovely as you. If I was there when it happened and I witnessed it I would have told/ confronted those girls in front of the whole school and told the police the truth about what happened to you. I hope you do find peace and that more people will believe your story and believe it as much as I do.
    R.I.P Carmen

  82. emmycakes says

    tbh i think the girls who pushed carmen down the sewer deserved what they got because no one should be treated the way carmen was. all she wanted was a friend and everyone treated her horribly for no reason at all. if i went to the same school as her back then i would’ve been her friend.

  83. SNGNation says

    I’m 100% on Carmens side they honestly deserve it, people who do that are disgusting and shouldn’t bully people they are the same as you, you shouldn’t hurt them if you see people getting bullied or you have a feeling someone is getting bullied tell a teacher or a councillor and they will help that person, Carmen didn’t deserve at all and the people who did it to her deserve it. #StopBullying

  84. isla says

    So so sad I hate bullies they shouldn’t of done what they did!!! I’m defiantly on Carmen’s side 100%! She was so innocent at least she got her revenge! Rip <3

  85. alexispatton says

    Omg Carmen I am 100% on your side and i understand how u felt I have been bullied several times I get sad and I wish they would stop. PS I love your name and I hope u like what I said. They are so mean to kill such an nice and sweet girl like u. I am SO SO SO SO SO sorry Carmen and they deserved what u did to them. They so deserved that. I also believe your story 100%. I sent it to my best friend and she doesnโ€™t believe it I wish she would.

  86. keygrover says

    I’m so sorry Carmen those girls shouldn’t of done what they did and then lied about it to the police they deserve what was coming for them I’ve been bullied a lot to but not compared to you RIP Carmen
    PS I beleive your story 100% of the way

  87. Blooderella says

    Poor Carmen! I feel so bad for you! Trust me, I know your pain because I’ve actually been physically bullied before! Those girls got what they deserved! They should have been arrested for murder and suffer their entire lives! Carmen good job! On your side!

  88. hannababee6803 says

    R.I.P Carmen Winstead. Its so tragic the way you passed away. Those girls got what they deserved they should’ve went to Jail for Murder and spend life and suffered. Those girls were so cruel. But Rest In Peace Carmen. Live in happiness and peace. Carmen I belevie what you did was right. I don’t understand how nobody saw those girls push you. R.I.P Carmen. Sending wishes and prayers in heaven. ๐Ÿ‘ผ๐Ÿ‘ผ๐Ÿ‘ผ๐Ÿ‘ผ๐Ÿ‘ผ๐Ÿ’˜๐Ÿ’˜๐Ÿ’˜๐Ÿ’Œ๐Ÿ’Œ๐Ÿ’Œ๐Ÿ’Œ๐Ÿ’ฌ๐Ÿ’ฌ๐Ÿ’ฌ
    Fly High Carmen Windstead.
    PS. I really like the name Carmen

  89. PurpleGirlTheHorrorFan says

    Carmen, I feel you, and believe you completely. I have been bullied, too, verbally. I think those girls deserved it. I mean how brutal can someone be? First torturing her. Then Pushing the girl into SEWER and giggling about it. They are b**ches. They don’t even CARE that they just ended somebody’s life, but they still decide that its no big deal and LAUGH. idiots.

  90. kansn says

    Wow I’m sorry you had to go threw this Carmen. I’ve been bullied and my sister was to. It’s hard to come by, I can’t believe those girls would do that to you, you would of have so much to live for if it wasn’t for those girls. I believe in you and what you did was right!!. Love you Carmen if you were alive I would be your friend most diffiently

  91. Jomo x Criss says

    Awww :( I feel so sorry for you Carmen,honestly. I have been bullied a few times. It feels awful. Bullies are brainless idiots. If I were there I would teach those bullies a lesson. I wish to support you. :) R.I.P Carmen,she will be missed. <3 PS I believe in your story 100% That's way extreme for you to lie.

  92. magykalocean says

    I feel really bad for Carmen Winstead, who would want to do that to a person, and then lie to the police officers about the crime!!! I FEEL SAD ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ!!!!!!!!!!!

  93. evan says

    Carmen I’m sorry about what happened to you. I might bully people sometimes. But now that I’ve gotten the message it scared me to life because when I got it I was going to the bathroom. So now I will stop so please please please please please please please please please please please please please please don’t kill me or hurt me. I’m sorry I do believe in you now. HAPPY NEW YEAR CARMEN!!

  94. BBVolcano says

    oh Carmen I am so sorry for what happened to you I believe your story 100%. I had that once when all my friends betrayed me because I hanged with the boy’s. But it was nothing compared to what you had. I AM SO SORRY FOR YOU

  95. Bloody Axe says

    I feel so sorry for you Carmen.I am against bullying too.I have been bullied too,but it was nothing compared to what you had to go through.I believe you 100%.RIP Carmen.

  96. Phillip Mweemba says

    I’m so sorry Carmen .what kind of evil person would do that to another human being.
    just know that We Love you Carmen xxxx you will forever be in our hearts .I know what it’s like to be bullied. I’ve been bullied in my life. you deserve justice. you will be remembered xxxxxxxxxxxxx I hope you see this Carmen. and I Believe

  97. RandomFangirl says

    I 100% believe you, bullies are the most WORST thing in this world. I truly wish that people wouldn’t do things like this. Pushing people down a sewer? Are they dumb or something? Don’t they know that’ll kill someone?

  98. HarryP says

    The first time i read this, i wanted to comment but i wasn’t logged in. Very touching story, so sorry for her parents and sibs. Now whats wrong with school kids?

  99. icydaisys says

    I believe you Carmen you shouldn’t have to put up with all that crap bullies should be the ones that this horrible stuff should happen to you go girl!

  100. tiffanygarza23 says

    Rip carmen , I don’t know why someone would do something so mean those girls should been thought better ! I’m so sorry tho happend to you I couldn’t imagine I got picked on when I was younger because of. My speech and I hated it ! So I kinda know how you feel but what you went through was 100 % worse and I’m so so sorry !!!

  101. ireallylikethenameSerenaty says

    I feel so bad for Carmen, she never got to live her whole life. She probably had so many good things that woulve happened in the future. There are so many horrible people in this world. R.I.P Carmen
    I believe 100%

  102. QuinnC2404 says

    This is a horrible thing to happen… Why anyone would do such a thing to someone so innocent is beyond me. Society is terrible. I feel so sorry for Carmen. Sleep well angel xx

  103. Aizy says

    Some ghosts just want justice
    Some ghosts just want revenge
    I think carmen wants both
    I feel bad for carmen
    if I was her I would feel the same way
    But worse

  104. slendy_iz_scary says

    BTW i believe in u Carmen no one should bully its stupid and retarded and we all feel bad for u but seriously those girls deserved it they are mean and stupid and pushing someone down the stairs is just wrong who does that

  105. slendy_iz_scary says

    great now I have two toilet ghosts coming after me 0_0
    but, bullying is awful no one should do it im gonna put this on instagram if I can type it all XD

  106. rainbowdashie says

    i believe it all! i have been bullied many times and i dont think its right to put a girl through such suffering like that just because she is new!!!!!

  107. Lori Quills says

    I beilieve every word of it. Those girls that did that deserved what they got. I feel so bad for Carmen. ;( She sounds like a very nice person and should have been treated nicer. I know how mean bullies can be but those girls are WICKED EVIL >:( I’m sorry this happened Carmen just know you are a leader. Ps I believe you Carmen :) ~Lori Quills

  108. superspooks29 says

    awww poor carmen
    i hate bullies and they should get what they deserve
    but i don’t think that the other classmates should have been killed because they probably did not know what really happened
    good job on the story

  109. pandaswag567carmeninourhearts says

    Those girls suck Carmen u are all of our bestest friends and I believe that u are real and u are pretty and I feel so sorry for you you are in my heart I believe that u exist

  110. nightisascaryday says

    People u should not bully what will u get only evilness and hatred from everyone I belive in you Carmen R.I.P I would really just love to be your friend as I really don’t have so many true friends I belive in you :)

  111. owenpolley says

    What happened to Carmen is true. When the girls pushed her down the sewer thinking it was funny, i did not. Bullying is what i get out of this and that is a major problem in the world today. Carmen deserves a place in everyones hearts and she has a part in mine for sure. For those who think this is fake then you better watch out because it’s 100% true. Carmen you are a great person and those people that pushed you down the sewer deserved to die because they made you suffer basically your whole life. Carmen i just want you to know (if you happen to read this) that you own a spot as big as you wish in my heart and i could’t feel more bad for a person in my life. <3 <3 <3

  112. Newyork1e says

    I feel so bad for Carmen and I believe her story those 5 girls deserved to die what mean people

  113. mrdalekjd says

    Don’t worry I hope you are in a better place.the world is full of evil and so much hatred.I would be your ntt forever.those girls were acting mean with you.you deserve way better.

  114. scary ghost fan says

    I don’t know HOW to share it with friends But…I believe you Carmen please don’t kill…ME.

  115. xx scarygurl xx says

    poor kid :( thats really mean i bieleive that she was pushed!!!! dont ever bully!! its wrong :'(

  116. JustCreeped says

    Poor carmen i believe in you i would’ve been your best friend you seem like the best girl ever i love u carmen as a sister already those girls deserved it i hope you read this carmen :) !

  117. scarymama says

    My yonger sister will not go to the bathroom or take a shower we have to fight with her to wash her hands. Bullies have gone to far

  118. kenzied1320 says

    Carmen, I am sooooo sorry for what happened to u like really half of my brains saying no dont belive this… but I do </3

  119. ScaredEasilyByNothin says

    I feel so sorry for carmin, I am on her side cause im like her in a way, R.I.P: Carmin Winstead

  120. ilikebeingdifferent23 says

    Don’t worry Carmen. I’ve been through all of that. All the bullies at my school lie many many times and the teachers never believed me. Those girls sure are BIG FAT bullies! Carmen, may you please help me? I’m just tired of being bullied and I believe your story. Don’t worry, you have a friend.

  121. GhostGirl1607 says

    WHAT!!! Ok 1st that was a super great story, but the thing is who does that to an innocent girl. She should have told her teacher the 1st time she got bullied instead of waiting I would tell my parents if i was get bullied like that and if they found out I was in a situation like that then oooooh loord those girls would be in TTTTRRRROOOUUUBBBBBBBLLLLLLEEEEEE

  122. Jojo says

    wow. That is one angry girl. I mean, okay yeah I have been bullied and it is horrible, so RIP Carmen, but to kill innocent people? That is just as bad (actually worse) than what those cruel girls did to her.

  123. monster_life says

    All of you guys are really just saying these things because you think the curse is real. I REALLY believe this curse because I’ve experienced bullying and I wish I could see the group who bullied me cuz then they would know that I’m not the one. That’s okay bcuz im much better than them.

  124. Anna says

    i hate bullies. though i have never come across bullies till now as far as i remember nor do i bully anyone. it is a very bad and cruel practice done by evil and heartless girls. I really feel very sorry for dear Carmen. how she lost her life because of the only five friends she had. how they cheated on her!

  125. ghostdude 515 says

    I got the txt today and I’m all creeped out. I believe the story R.I.P Carmen. I would have been your friend. :/ R.I.P

  126. The Beliver says

    I know how she feels I’m bullied too. The thing is if I were to get revenge I would go and get revenge on the people that did that two me not any other people. Once I got my revenge on the people that did that I would be fine. I believe her because the people in this world are not the nicest people you will meet and others are nice, but whatever Carmen Winstead I believe you 100%.

  127. Candy1239 says

    By the way Carmen R.I.P.I believe you 100%. I hope you find peace. Oh and i would have pushed the 5 girls out of the way and got Carmen out of the mess.

  128. SuperFunGirl says

    Omgod…Y did she die the bullies deserve to die im on carmens side i HATE BUllies i wouldve saved her life but i woul tell the teacher right away if someone bullied me it was both fault atleast she went to heavan to see god and jesus bUT th girls bullies went to hell to see the devil .Poor carmen i would been crying. Carmen just wanted friends wut did she expect those girls were REALLY mean she mustve been reallly nice carmen Hvae a very good night Rip u r missed<3 Have a good time in heavan its better up there TRUST ME the world is cruel because of the government doesnt care he only cares about OUR money

  129. terrorzombie says

    DEAR CARMEN: if u are reading this i want to say that i do believe u and on behalf of those girls SORRY u should have never been treated like that i mean if u were in my class i would have treated u like a human being not like those 5 girls who treated u as if u weren’t in this world. I HOPE UR SOUL GETS PEACE

  130. fearchedder911 says

    I do believe the story of Carmen I really do I know how mean people can be I’ve been bullied countless times I know how she feels Im so sorry for her and her family I know it’s a hard time and I know that Carmen is mad at the girls for telling the lie and the class mates who didn’t believe either but I do and I know other people do to so again I apologize for the hard things she’s gone through but I do believe her story. I am with Carmen Iโ€™ve been bullied over my weight Iโ€™ve been trying to lose weight Iโ€™ve lost 20 pounds and Iโ€™m happy about I donโ€™t care what people say and Iโ€™m with Carmen I donโ€™t hate bullies I just dislike them I just want to say Iโ€™m with Carmen. Carmen I hope you find peace I know how you feel Iโ€™ve always have been bullied I believe you 100% no doubt

  131. warrenkylehood says

    I was under my bkanket this mornin at 6:25 and it felt like someome held me down……..I don’t wanna die!!!!!!!!!!!

  132. eywa12 says

    Carmen, If you are reading this, I nearly cried when I heard your story. I’m so sorry that that happened to you. I know what it’s like to be bullied. Though she didn’t push me down a sewer, I feel your hate and your pain. I just want you to know, you aren’t alone.

  133. Emma123 says

    OMG I feel so bad for you Carmen! The girls deserved to die. I’m a geek but I don’t get bullied. I have hatred towards the popular girls and I pulled pranks on them all year last year! I’m gonna do it again this year too! I sure get a kick out of their reactions! By the way I beleive your story Carmen 100%!

  134. I call myself demented says

    Who puts crap in someone’s pocket?!?!?!?!?! How did she know that it was dog poop? That would be so freaking gross.

  135. awesomo12 says

    I’ll take my chance with the chain letter. My friend sent it to me and i’m not going to send it to other people.

  136. Rocky says

    i believe in this story. the girls whom pushed Carmen should be punished. Carmen should not get this treatment. I know how it feels to be bullied because i was in a public school before and there were kids who bullied me. bullying makes it hard to do things i wanted to do. i was scared to go to school for like 3 weeks. then my parents moved me to a private school and i feel great not to be bullied every day. i am glad though back to the topic. i do feel really bad for carmen.

  137. DarkDragon says

    i believe it damn that’s gruesome and believable those 5 girls are monsters Carmen didn’t deserve that iknow how it feels to be bullyed i feel sorry for her

  138. Darcykat says

    Carmen deserved friends she was such an innocent girl and she seemed sweet according to the writing. The police were dumb to believe them. Those girls are in hell right now I hope. Rest in peace Carmen! I don’t know you, but I wish I did when you were alive. Maybe me and my friends could help you and give those girls a lesson. I will never bully anyone in my life. I love Carmen, she deserves the best in heaven

  139. alp123 says

    I believe this story and think that those girls deservered to die. WHO WOULD DO THAT???!!?? Then lie and tell the police that they witnessed it but didn’t do that. That’s just rude!!! R.I.P Carmen Winstead

  140. lauren_wallace says

    Thts sooo sad!!! It really scared me because five of the people tht I thought were my friends recently started bullying me for no reason at all and I’ve been threatened to be murdered so I a lil scared now!!!!!!

  141. lacole luv99 says

    Poor girl!Those girls got what they deserved!How do u expect to push someone down a sewer and think that they would be ok!!!???They are soo mean,i always be nice to new kids.rest in peace carmen i am on your side.TEAM CARMEN FOREVER:)

  142. lonergurl says

    I believe this story. bullies need to stop before they get hurt. i feel sorry for this girl beaceuse i know what it is like to get bullied and i didnt like it but i got it to stop before it got to far. i wish someone would have helped that poor girl. she trusted those girls and they turned on her. i hate bullies and hate people when they see it and dont stop it. people we need to stand against the bullies once and for all!

  143. rose13pink says

    I believe this story and I believe bullies can be this mean but there is no reason for it!

  144. hausofanatolia says

    Those… Monsters! This story is so sad I feel sorry for Carmen if I were in that school I would be friends with her forever<3 If I was there I would have saved her!

  145. residentevil5589 says

    omg i belive that! horrrible! those grls were B*tches, and thatz the thruth, ill never bully any1 EVAH

  146. paranormalprincess18 says

    Those girls totally deserved what they got! They shouldn’t have been mean to poor Carmen!

  147. Chocco says

    Carmen im so sorry remember that im witj u l.i remember i read on a stone tha little girl tried to get her ball that fell down a well and instead she fell down and dird at a young age.im so sorry carmen for what happend to u carmen if i was with u at ur new school i wouldvbeen ur bff>best freind forever.i get bulled to allot at my school to im a loner.

  148. Emily says

    I got the forward and didn’t send it then at night I kept waking up then after 5 hours i heard a weird giggle not laughter. I freaked out like crazy! I said to my self I belive in Carmen then the giggling stoped I stayed up for a bit then fell asleep. Let’s see if it happens again tonight….

  149. Alexia says

    You do know that the story is wrong the mother is the one who pushed her down a well.. that’s the way the true story goes…

  150. BrookeBabe says

    ok, i feel sorry for this girl. it makes me sad when bullies hurt people and don’t get blamed.

  151. 101horrorgirl101 says

    poor carmen!!!!!!!!!!! i feel bad for her! I also have this thing with bathrooms and mirrors , so i am a little freaked out!

  152. Monkeymadmia says

    There is a bully in my class at school she is mean to me, she teases me, she calls me names, she once gave me a black eye as well! She also pounded me into the ground and said “I hope I pound you so hard your heart stops beating so you die!” AHHHHHHH! What the heck is she going to do next!? o.O

  153. lovelinds99 says

    Last year i recieved a txt message from my boyfriend. my mom picked it up and read the winstead story she freaks out and rushed to me. i read it. I called him and asked y he wanted to kill me, he said to send it to 10 ppl cuz he cared for me.i didnt do it. i didnt believe it, my mom was then awoken to a weird noise and a laughter. she woke the whole house up, I found that since she opened the message she was the one cursed. so i made her send it to ppl. we summened the carmen ghost and since then we hear weird noises in the drain, toilet and shower. I know feel sorrow for carmen winstead and know that this haunting is real.

  154. babygirl55 says

    after reading this i will never bully someone agian this almost made me cry it is soo sad:/.. im soo sorry carmen and.. to throw this out there if ur reading this i dont see why someone would want to kill u like that your really prettty!.. R.I.P!… i would of been your friend….

  155. girly101 says

    i feel so bad for carmen them girlz deserved what they got. schools need to stop bullying and if i went to the same school as her i would have been her bestie forever and from the pics i seen she is very pretty and i hope she r.i.p luv u carmen we will never forget you

  156. elmeromero says

    This sounds sad but I’f it was real. I seriously don’t believe a girl can kill people and make them appear in a sewer. I got this message and I google it and found this. I do feel bad for her but if This was real they wouldent make a website of This. The government would make this top secret if This was true. I don’t know it does seem kinda real. Bit I don’t have a opinion such as I do belie and I don’t. I jsit dont know what to think.

  157. musiclover6200 says

    OMG. Those chicks are rotten! And just because Carmen was new. That’s just sick. I feel ya, Carmen. I just don’t send forwards. In fact, half the forwards like this that I get, I believe, but nobody in my contacts list likes forwards. So I can’t. The thing I dont get is why was he sewer open? That’s a hazard, obviously. If the city had had that manhole covered, Carmen wouldn’t have been able to fall in. Carmen, if you’re reading this, I would suggest haunting the city council of wherever it happened. Sorry I couldn’t forward, love ya!

  158. Hippyhannah says

    Oh my gosh, Carmen i feel so bad for you, noone should ever be treated like that. Those girls should have never done that to you.I wish you could have stayed back with your friends.No one and i mean NO ONE deserves to be treated like that,EVER.and Carmen i feel bad for you,and i know how you feel i’ve been the new girl and ran into troubles like WAY more than once. Rest in Peace. i’m so sorry.

  159. mackenzie says

    I think that bulllying is wrong and that knowone should be doing it ive been bullied before and i dont like it i feel bad for carmen.

  160. stocky says

    how could u do that to someone some people take things way too far and i 1000% believed she was pushed how could the police believe she fell idiots!!. i recieved the text and didnt believe it at first but i feel soo bad now as now i know its true im very sorry carmen ill be ur mate anyday bffs babe

  161. dancegirl1597 says

    Poor carmen!!! I cannot believe these evil girls who pushed her down a SEWER!!! How evil….they deserved to die!!! I would have been her friend, she seemed nice!!! :)

  162. chibimaru15000 says

    omg wen i read this story i cried. carmen did not deserve to die she was sweet,beautiful,quiet,and innocent. i’m a christian so i cant say they deserved to die but wat they did was horrible. i always wonder if they felt guilty after they did it.if i went to her school i would definetly be friends with carmen and defend her from all those horrible people.i will always be on ur side carmen. may she rest in peace.god bless all. R.I.P CARMEN. o and 1 more thing, wen i 1st got the carmen message i was so scared i started crying but now i that i read this i feel so sorry for her. i luv u carmen.

  163. jessie says

    i got a forward about carmen n i sent it to 10 people thats local to text right now n i seen a pic of her n she is a pretty girl i feel so bad for her

  164. bobbyjo.aj says

    I know how it feels to be bullied and new to a school. I have moved to several new schools and i have had people say things like i have lice, (wich i have never had in my life), and that i am a caveman. Girls are b****es and i know this from experience. I am with carmen all the way. And for all those who read this…Life is a b**** and people are mean but just try to ignore them and move on… luv you carmen rest in peace :)

  165. lilbabe97 says

    OMG,so sad.this fraked me out when i got the message on my phone so i googled it. Im luv carmen like she was my own friend i would never of treated her like that.im ion your side carmen.xxx

  166. idiotppl says

    guys. i got this forward and didn’t send it to the 10 ppl. so they found my body in the sewer with my neck broken and my face skin ripped off.

  167. Lexxie64 says

    for all we know Carmen could have been a bitch -.- anyways yea it was tragic but the 5 girls didn’t need to die … let me explain b4 you hate me its cuz death isn’t the end of all life its only a break from it with every death there’s a rebirth and Carmen isn’t any better then the girls that pushed her down the sewer because she did it to the only way to live a peaceful life is to forgive maybe not forget but at the least not sink their level which Carmen did

  168. paddy says

    im so sorry for you carmen . i do believe you , and im not saying this to save my life…. but please realise that people are sorry for you , and everyone do believe you . you have also taken revenge on the people you hate . so please realise that your duties are over and join the father in heaven above . i am sure that the five girls who killed you are suffering in hell . i think it is time you rest in peace .i wish good for your soul and want it to atttain salvation .

  169. Madi says

    Thats just wrong big time! If i was there and saw it, I would have told the police that those 5 little brats killed you! I believe every single word from that story, they deserved to die not you. RIP Carmen.

  170. princessblondie says

    i belive this story is true but but some people have made diffrent things to it its very sad r.i.p carmen them girls deserves what happened to them xx

  171. lottie12 says

    look she is real me and my friends have researched everything and as long as you believe in her you shouldnt be scared she wont hurt you! My friends and i (me lottie and my two friends chloe and rebecca) all love you and we wish you were here now! bye xx carmen xxx

  172. Brookewalker says

    Wow, thats horrible. Im so sorry carmen. Carmen didnt deserve to die. She was just a teenage girl going through a hard time. I honestly don’t think those girls deserved to die, because no one deserves to face death as cruecial as that, but I do think they should’ve been severly punished. But we all love carmen… R.I.P.

  173. laynavb1230 says

    This is so sad. Kids these days are just so mean. I want to know how they could go to sleep knowing that they had killed someone. I’m sorry Carmen!

  174. singergal84 says

    OMG my friend sent me this text and even tho I sent it I was so freaked out I slept in my parents room, Then my friend sent it to me again and even tho I sent it before I sent it again, I really want to know if this is real or not so I can stop worrying. PLEASE DONT SEND ME FORWORDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  175. Allij8 says

    Omg Carmen i am on your side if i went to that school i would have befriended u immidiatley u did not diserve to get bullied they did all of those girls diserve to die not u! how can someone be so cruel???!!!. U had the right to kill them! But i got this fwd and it said send to 20 people or u will get ur neck broken and face pealed off and be in a sewer and u’ll be dead so i sent it to 20 people. but Carmen did not diserve to die!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  176. Maggie23 says

    At first I didn’t believe it when I got the Text Message, then the more I thought about it the more scared I got.. I quickly sent it, and felt good. This is truly a scary story… I hope she can finally rest in piece one day, on that day, only believers will be left.

    R.I.P. Carmen Winstead

  177. caitlyn1217 says

    OMG!!! I believe that she was pushed down a sewer 150%! I mean, with her age, what kind of person would just “fall” down a sewer. You would see it, and not go down it… but, those bullies are mean. they deserved to die. If i was her friend, i would stand up for her, and rather me get pushed down a sewer than her, i mean, i bet she was a nice, kind, open hearted girl. But, these bullies have no heart!!!!! Those 5 girls are in Hell where they can rot and they deserve to be there. With carmen, she is in Heaven where she belongs because like I said, i bet she was a kind, open hearted girl.

  178. Michelle says

    i think its really sad..and no one should do that to people,to anyone. people need to be nice!

  179. smileykiid says

    wow that’s not right ii feel bad for Carmen ii bet she was a very beautiful girl and the onlii reason why those low life girls did that is because they’re insecure about themselves and they were trying to show off but it wasn’t even cool wha theii did how could they look the cop in the eye and lie ? smh welps! there in hell now so they can rot there, as for Carmen she’s probably in a better place =] ily Carmen even tho ii neva met u u seemed like a cool girl and ii would’ve been your friend..
    STOP BULLYING <<<

  180. KittyKat566 says

    I feel bad for Carmen first off being relocated to a new state new school and leaving all your best friends behind…Then being literally tortured with they’re cruel pranks…I definitely believe this legend is 100% true and I also believe those girls that murdered Carmen pushing her down a sewer deserved what they got…to die and Carmen…I’m on your side definitely
    -KittyKat

  181. ddr895 says

    Immmmmm am sooooo srry tht happened to u….tht was wrong of those 5 girls to do tht to u….i dont understand why people would do something tht cruel…..im very srry tht happened…..i can understand how u feel and other girls do to….cuz they have been bullied and i have toooo… they would call me names and chase me and push me down….im srry very srry

  182. ScreamSPARKSx3 says

    I just got this in a foward message , I didn’t believe it so I googled it but woow this really creeped me out. Pooor Carmen, I never been bullied but I never bully people. Why would you? Its just makes you look mean & such an ugly person. Its good what those 5 girls got! RiP Carmen x3

  183. Aweee says

    Oh And I Believe yhu. I Do Believe. Awwww Carmen . I Feel so bad ]: i was bullied too. i hate it. They talked about my dad who is gone forever. D: im so sorry what happened to you Carmen ]: R.I.P

  184. justin13 says

    that is some bull i would of left it alone.. and i would never in my life kill some one i believe this is true carmen i will always be your friend because ppl need friends and those 5 girls will never of never made friends if they were still alive if i have a friend i would try to treat them nice i wouldnt be like those 5 girls i would take care of my friends and be nice to them i would any way……..i love you cARMEN

  185. soccergurl101 says

    Those girls were soooo mean and wrong to do that to her they should really take resposibility for their actions. I feel bad for Carmen

  186. hippie40 says

    THATS HORRIBLE WHAT THEY DID TO HER!!! As if Carmen hadnt had enough with them bullying her they just killed her and then to lie about it! Poor Carmen what did she ever do to them i mean nobody deserves to die but it was horrible what they did.

  187. i luv dogs says

    those girls deserved to be dead b’cuz i believe and I’m on Carmen’s side (i believe i believe i believe i believe)

  188. ImABeliever1029 says

    This is crazy!!!!! I wish tht this nvr happend. We all care about you Carmen and we miss you. R.I.P. Carmen. I wish tht you had stayed back where you lived. Most of all I wish those girls nvr did tht to you. If you went to my school I would want to be best friends!!! I love new ppl at my school bc regular ppl get boring. Miss you. R.I.P. and we miss you. :) <3 you

  189. luvu4eva says

    that is soooooo mean!!! i always try 2 welcum the new kid cuz if that was me i wudnt want that 2 happen!! those girls got what they deserved!!! i luv u carmen

  190. zooey1019 says

    omg i’m soooo sorry carmen RIP. wow girl thats just f’d what those bitchy girls did to u and not telling the truth to the cops what dumb asses they deserve what they got. Everytime i get ur forward i send it to 10 friends just like the forward says i truly believe in your story bcuz most girls r bitches im sooooooo sorry for what those evil crule ppl did to u like those messed up students for laughing when those evil bitches pushed u into the sewer.And those kids where in highschool i thought they would b more mature than that what imature jerks. RIP CARMEN WINSTEAD oh yea sweetie i would b ur friend anyday and everyday. Theres many ppl who care about u love ya girly! RIP <3

  191. Evilxcloud says

    Those 5 girls are **** and deserve to die after (KILLING) a person who just moved into indiana i hear alot of bad things happend but this is terrible i hope carmen rests in peace btw i dont really foward most messages but i only sent it to 5 people i trust and know but the same thing here happens to me at school. this one kid choked me for owning him in volley ball :P and this one kid pulled my head back for stepping on his shoes during soccer :P “Its an Imperfect World but its the only one we got.”

  192. lottie12 says

    hey..xx Carmen me and my friend’s chloe,hollie and miriam are all on your side,okay.Because you did nothing wrong to hurt them five girls and they pushed the line there and then didnt they.. So me,chloe,hollie and miriam think that you should torture them even more.(Even know they’re dead now.)You should still hurt them,over what they did. They had deffinitely crossed the line.
    when me,chloe,hollie and miriam die, we are going to hurt them as much as they hurt you,okay,dont you worry. Me and my friend’s love you carmen winstead and think that you are one of those girls who are special. We think that you should of lived a more happier life than what them girls did to you.
    P.S Me,Chloe,Hollie and Miriam thought and still do think that you are a very pretty,young girl who deserved a much happier and longer life. WE ALL LOVE YOU!(me,chloe,hollie and miriam.)XxXx.

  193. lottie12 says

    carmen is a very kind-hearted girl and i love her to bits she was so pretty as well. When i die i am going to torture them 5girls like hey did to you carem winstead dont you worry.xxi love you..xx

  194. lottie12 says

    hey..xx Carmen, i don’t blame you for getting back at those stupid discustingly evil girls. I would of done the exact same thing. YOU GO GIRL. And dont worry you dont need to come after me because i believe everything about your story. That is very horrible,about what they did to you and they should really be ashaimed of them selfs shouldnt they. And i would of made you my bestest friend ever because you seem like a very kind-hearted girl and i would of loved for you to be my bffl. Well done carmen winstead for getting back at those stupid girls i HATE them they are just horrible. WELL DONE. Im with you.x

  195. BiEbEr_FeVeR says

    IM TOTALLY FREAKED OUT NOW MAN!!!!!!!!(i believe..i believe..i believe..i believe)

  196. Jordiee44 says

    No seriously though who would do such a sick thing to an innocent girl, They should’ve put themselves in carmens shoes!!!!!! I would’ve made her my bffl!! I love making new friends and welcoming new people :) Those people got a taste of their own medicine! :) well done carmen :)

  197. chipmunckfan says

    i feel very sorry for carmen them 5 girls should of told the truth and they didnt so they should of died and i belive carmens story

  198. HelloBeautiful363 says

    this wasnt fair at all! she did NOT deserve to die, and she does have the right to get the 5 girls back, i mean, that was just rude and Carmon is beautiful and she was very very nice to everybody, and i bet the 5 girls were jealous of her and they had no way to handle it so they did that/ but that was just not right. IM SORRY CARMON!! </3

  199. truetexan19 says

    what kind of person would do that? and then lie about it? where im from you dont do that to people. carmens is doing right by her revenge

  200. cazy101 says

    carmen them girls got what they deserved and i know i believe in this and you did not deserve what you got and you where a new kid you thought they where your friends but they were just using you

  201. sh33laE says

    i hope thse girls learned there lesson. I would be Carmen’s bestie forever and i bet there was nothing wrong with her and the girls just wanted to bother her for no reason. I would totally defend her

  202. Deya10 says

    poor poor carmen i feel bad 4 those bad stupid retarded cruel ppl that pushed her down the sewer they were so mean to carmen 4 no reason.gud job carmeen 4 pushing them down the sewer and putting them through the misery that u went through b-cuz of them!!!!!!!

  203. capone69 says

    poor girl im sorry carmen. i always tryed my best 2 make girls feel welcome at school or at work R,I,P carmen we love u<3 those girls got wat u gave them. I wish that hade never happend to u. i belive they pushed u i knw how girls are…

  204. kelsey8888 says

    hi carmen this is kelsey8888’s friend and i just want to say that i believe you and i am so sorry for wat has happened to you i get bullied too all the time so i know how it feels and i feels pretty bad and just like kelsey8888 i would have loved to be your friend you are a strong and beautiful girl and i bet your parents are very proud of you for putting up with it that long just always remember there is ppl thinking about you every day and night and are in the same situation that you were

  205. kelsey8888 says

    Carmen oh my god i feel so sorry for you i know where you are getting at i understand that if someone doesnt believe you….you get mad and upset bcuz you want to be here to tell the story i get bullied to not just by girls but by boys to i would tell the teacher to i am so sorry that stupid ppl like that would do that from what i have seen you are beautiful and i would’ve loved to be your friend any day!!!!

  206. Nya says

    Thats so sad. I hate people who bully others. Its a never ending cycle that should have an end.

  207. EpicNinjaRawrz says

    =O how could anyone be so mean, i totally believe her story, i am always friends with new girls to make them feel safe and secure, those girls were asking for it, she was pushed

  208. ILoveDerek says

    I can’t believe what happened that poor girl…Before I become homeschooled, I used to get picked on by a big group of girls to. They were friggen jerks…
    How does anyone NOT know that if you push someone down a damn sewer, that person is gonna get hurt? HOW DO THEY NOT KNOW THAT??? Those girls deserved to die for all the suffering they put Carmen through… R.I.P. Carmen…

  209. cherry88 says

    well,i think the world should be fair carmen winstead was hated by her classmates and i think that the five girls were not fair to her like she was to her i dont know why some people in scchool are like that people in school sometimes are like that to me im friendly to them and they repaid me like that
    “THE WORLD IS NOT FAIR LIKE IT SHOULD BE “

  210. tasha says

    really cried when i read this story it is heartbreakin nd if i was her friend noone wouldnt be able to touch her. Carmen Winstead u luv in my heart fo life nd others to. I MISS U lik u were already my friend iluh u gurl<3 friends fo life... we do it big. P.C.E.

  211. loversndfriends says

    awww my brother sent me the chain about carmen, who he got from his friend my brother and i both are on carmens side because ive been bullied and ive been picked on. those 5 girls shud deserve waht has happened to them for pushing a poor innocent gurl down the sewer.i really feel bad for u carmen (:

  212. gigglez says

    what those 5 girls did was mest upp they crossed the line!!!!!!!!!!!!! im on carmens side cuz iv been bulled many times and i know how it feels

  213. maxypoo_6 says

    When i got the text of carmen i felt really bad and sent it to 20 people. Thats really sad the chicks deserve to die. I would go back and haunt and kill them too. I fell really bad for carmen. She is such a pretty girl. That would suck to be her. If i was her friend i wouldnt do that to her! I would be there for her and be her bestfriend

  214. cherrygirl3199 says

    how can someone be so mean and have such a dark evil heart as those girls to do such bad things to someone,i imagin carmen probably was a very kind hearted young girl and a very good friend.if i had bine there i would have protected her from all those stupid evil girls that ended carmens kind pure life with such tragety. im always on carmens side she was always right and those girls were entiarly wrong. “love u carmen bffs forever always on your side :)” <3333.

  215. mj123 says

    I got a text about her on my phone and after I read it I had the chills for the rest of the day and yet I watch rated R moives!

  216. SONICFAN12 says

    i got a forwrd from my friend in the middle of class.it says if you dont forward it to 10 ppl you will die the same ways she did.its fake.when i got it im like oh brother.i didnt send it to 10 ppl.and it didnt work but i feel like beliving its true because it so interesting.

  217. HorrorJoker16 says

    The world is so cruel. Those girls shouldn’t be so mean to someone as innocent as Carmen.

Leave a Reply