Carmen Winstead
The story of Carmen Winstead is a chain letter about a 17 year old girl who died when she was pushed down a sewer by five girls she thought were her friends.
Carmen was 17 years old when her parents decided to move to Indiana. Her father had lost his job and the only way he could find new employment was by moving to a new state. The relocation caused a lot of problems for Carmen. She had to leave her friends behind and attend a whole new school in Indiana.
Carmen had a hard time making friends when she changed schools. It was the middle of the school year and most of the students had no interest in befriending the new girl. Initially, she spent many days alone, walking from class to class without speaking to anyone, but she eventually started hanging around with a group of five other girls. Carmen thought these girls were her friends, but it wasn’t long before she discovered that they had been talking about her behind her back and spreading vile rumors.
When she confronted them, the girls turned on her and began bullying her every day, making her life a misery. They started out calling her names, but then the bullying got much worse. One day, she left her school books in the classroom at break time. When she returned, she found someone had taken a sharpie and written dirty words all over her books. Another day, she opened her bag and discovered someone had poured yoghurt all over the insides. Sometimes, she would come to school and find her locker had been vandalized. The final straw came when she put on her coat at recess and found that someone had stuffed dog poop in her pockets.
There and then, Carmen decided that she couldn’t take the bullying any longer. She planned to stay behind, that evening, after school, and tell her teacher what had been happening. Unfortunately, her decision came too late to save her life.
After lunch, her teacher announced that the school was holding a fire drill. When the alarm sounded, Carmen and the other students filed out of the classroom and assembled in the yard outside. As the teachers read out the roll call, the gang of five girls decided that this was a great opportunity to embarrass Carmen in front of the whole school during the fire drill. They moved over to where Carmen was standing, near a sewer drain, and began crowding the poor girl, getting in her face and nudging her towards the open manhole.
They pushed her and she tripped over and fell head-first down the manhole. When they saw her falling, the girls started giggling and when Carmen’s name was called out, they shouted “She’s down in the sewer!”
All of the other students began laughing. But when the teachers looked down the manhole and saw Carmen’s body lying at the bottom in the muck and the poop, the laughter abruptly stopped. Her head was twisted around at an odd angle and her face was covered in blood. Worse still, she wasn’t moving.
There was nothing any of the teachers could do for her. Carmen was dead. When the police arrived and went down into the sewer, they determined that she had broken her neck. Her face had been torn off when she hit the ladder on the way down and her neck snapped when she landed on her head on the concrete at the bottom.
The police hauled Carmen’s body out of the sewer and sent her to the mortuary. Everyone had to stay behind after school while the police questioned all of Carmen’s classmates. The five girls lied to the police, saying they had witnessed Carmen falling down the sewer. The police believed the girls and Carmen Winstead’s death was ruled an accident and the case was closed. Everyone thought that was the last they would hear of Carmen Winstead, but they were wrong.
Months later, Carmen’s classmates began receiving strange e-mails on their MySpaces. The e-mails were titled “They Pushed Her” and claimed that Carmen hadn’t really fallen down the sewer, she had been pushed. The e-mails also warned that the guilty people should own up and take responsibility for their crime. If they didn’t there would be horrible consequences. Most people dismissed the e-mails as a hoax, but others were not so sure.
A few days later, one of the girls who pushed Carmen down the sewer was at home taking a shower, when she heard a strange cackling laugh. It seemed to be coming from the drain. The girl started to freak out and ran out of the bathroom. That night, the girl said goodnight to her mom and went to sleep.
Five hours later, her mom was awoken in the middle of the night, by a loud noise that resounded throughout the house. She ran into her daughter’s room, only to find it empty. There was no trace of the girl. The worried mother called the police and when they arrived, they conducted a search of the area. Eventually, they discovered the girl’s grisly remains.
Her corpse was lying in the sewer, covered in muck and poop. Her neck was broken and her face was missing. It had been completely torn off. One by one, all of the girls who pushed Carmen that day were found dead. They had all been killed in exactly the same way and were all found at exactly the same spot. In the sewer at the bottom of the same uncovered manhole where Carmen had met her doom.
But the killing didn’t stop there. More and more of Carmen’s former classmates were found dead. It seemed that anyone who didn’t believe that Carmen had been pushed, was eventually found down in the sewer with their necks broken and their faces torn off.
They say that Carmen’s ghost is still on the rampage, hunting down anyone who doesn’t believe her story. According to the legend, Carmen will get you, whether it’s from a toilet, a shower, a sink or a drain. When you go to sleep, you’ll wake up in the sewer, in complete darkness, paralyzed, unable to move, hearing cackling laughter all around you. Then, as you scream in horror, Carmen will come and tear your face off.
So be careful who you bully, because you just might find yourself on the receiving end of the curse of Carmen Winstead.
poor carmen. those 5 girls deserved 2 die
Scary huh!!
creepy,
The world is so cruel. Those girls shouldn’t be so mean to someone as innocent as Carmen.
i got a forwrd from my friend in the middle of class.it says if you dont forward it to 10 ppl you will die the same ways she did.its fake.when i got it im like oh brother.i didnt send it to 10 ppl.and it didnt work but i feel like beliving its true because it so interesting.
omg, i feel so sorry 4 her….does girls r sooo mean!!!
I got a text about her on my phone and after I read it I had the chills for the rest of the day and yet I watch rated R moives!
poor girl. how could anyone be so mean. carmen didnt deserve to die.
poor girl i would have always been her best friend…and this world is so cruel
those girls r stupid WHO PUSHES SOME 1 DOWN A SEWER AND THINKS THEY WONT GET HURT?!?!?!?!?! the 5 girls deserved 2 die poor Carmen…
how can someone be so mean and have such a dark evil heart as those girls to do such bad things to someone,i imagin carmen probably was a very kind hearted young girl and a very good friend.if i had bine there i would have protected her from all those stupid evil girls that ended carmens kind pure life with such tragety. im always on carmens side she was always right and those girls were entiarly wrong. “love u carmen bffs forever always on your side :)” <3333.
When i got the text of carmen i felt really bad and sent it to 20 people. Thats really sad the chicks deserve to die. I would go back and haunt and kill them too. I fell really bad for carmen. She is such a pretty girl. That would suck to be her. If i was her friend i wouldnt do that to her! I would be there for her and be her bestfriend
those girls deserved 2 die poor carmen
what those 5 girls did was mest upp they crossed the line!!!!!!!!!!!!! im on carmens side cuz iv been bulled many times and i know how it feels
awww my brother sent me the chain about carmen, who he got from his friend my brother and i both are on carmens side because ive been bullied and ive been picked on. those 5 girls shud deserve waht has happened to them for pushing a poor innocent gurl down the sewer.i really feel bad for u carmen (:
Omg that is so sad 4 Carmen. Im on Carmen’s side cause that is sooo sad <3
really cried when i read this story it is heartbreakin nd if i was her friend noone wouldnt be able to touch her. Carmen Winstead u luv in my heart fo life nd others to. I MISS U lik u were already my friend iluh u gurl<3 friends fo life… we do it big. P.C.E.
i think those girls should not of pich on here that way they deserved what they got
well,i think the world should be fair carmen winstead was hated by her classmates and i think that the five girls were not fair to her like she was to her i dont know why some people in scchool are like that people in school sometimes are like that to me im friendly to them and they repaid me like that
“THE WORLD IS NOT FAIR LIKE IT SHOULD BE “
I can’t believe what happened that poor girl…Before I become homeschooled, I used to get picked on by a big group of girls to. They were friggen jerks…
How does anyone NOT know that if you push someone down a damn sewer, that person is gonna get hurt? HOW DO THEY NOT KNOW THAT??? Those girls deserved to die for all the suffering they put Carmen through… R.I.P. Carmen…
=O how could anyone be so mean, i totally believe her story, i am always friends with new girls to make them feel safe and secure, those girls were asking for it, she was pushed
this is so tragic! i feel so sorry for carmen! rest in peace carmen! those girls deserved to die. weall love you carmen!
POOR CARMEN ANY NEW GIRL SHOULD NOT BE TREATED LIKE THAT GOD SHE DIDNT DEXERVE IT
Thats so sad. I hate people who bully others. Its a never ending cycle that should have an end.
Carmen oh my god i feel so sorry for you i know where you are getting at i understand that if someone doesnt believe you….you get mad and upset bcuz you want to be here to tell the story i get bullied to not just by girls but by boys to i would tell the teacher to i am so sorry that stupid ppl like that would do that from what i have seen you are beautiful and i would’ve loved to be your friend any day!!!!
hi carmen this is kelsey8888’s friend and i just want to say that i believe you and i am so sorry for wat has happened to you i get bullied too all the time so i know how it feels and i feels pretty bad and just like kelsey8888 i would have loved to be your friend you are a strong and beautiful girl and i bet your parents are very proud of you for putting up with it that long just always remember there is ppl thinking about you every day and night and are in the same situation that you were
Awee , i feel so bad for that poor girl ): .
thats so sadd . ! : /
Best wishes qo out to her poor family. <3 & them girls shouldnt mess with that poor girl .
R.i.p carmen
poor poor carmen i feel bad 4 those bad stupid retarded cruel ppl that pushed her down the sewer they were so mean to carmen 4 no reason.gud job carmeen 4 pushing them down the sewer and putting them through the misery that u went through b-cuz of them!!!!!!!
poor girl im sorry carmen. i always tryed my best 2 make girls feel welcome at school or at work R,I,P carmen we love u<3 those girls got wat u gave them. I wish that hade never happend to u. i belive they pushed u i knw how girls are…
this is messed up she shouldnt have been treated like this and i think those 5 girls deserved it. its scary because my one friend sent me something like this in a forward
Poor Carmen:( those girls deserved what they got
Poor, poor, Carmen!those 5 girls deserved it! Carmen has her revenge and really deserves it! She deserves to get revenge on others who bullied her!
i hope thse girls learned there lesson. I would be Carmen’s bestie forever and i bet there was nothing wrong with her and the girls just wanted to bother her for no reason. I would totally defend her
carmen them girls got what they deserved and i know i believe in this and you did not deserve what you got and you where a new kid you thought they where your friends but they were just using you
MY FRIEND SENT ME THE CHAIN BOUT CARMEN. IF I WAS GOIN TO THAT SCHOOL WIT CAMREN N I WAS FTIENDS WIT CAMREN I. WOULD OF STOOD BY HER SIDE N HELP HER OUT. THAT IS SO SO CRUEL WAT THOSE FIVE GIRLS DID TO CARMEN ND THEY DESERVE WAT THOSE STUPID GIRLS GOT.
what kind of person would do that? and then lie about it? where im from you dont do that to people. carmens is doing right by her revenge
That story is so freakin’ sad… And weren’t people looking when Carmen was pushed? Also, if Carmen screamed, why didn’t anyone hear it? Carmen got her revenge fair-and-square so she needs to rest. R.I.P. Carmen!!
this wasnt fair at all! she did NOT deserve to die, and she does have the right to get the 5 girls back, i mean, that was just rude and Carmon is beautiful and she was very very nice to everybody, and i bet the 5 girls were jealous of her and they had no way to handle it so they did that/ but that was just not right. IM SORRY CARMON!! </3
i feel very sorry for carmen them 5 girls should of told the truth and they didnt so they should of died and i belive carmens story
No seriously though who would do such a sick thing to an innocent girl, They should’ve put themselves in carmens shoes!!!!!! I would’ve made her my bffl!! I love making new friends and welcoming new people :) Those people got a taste of their own medicine! :) well done carmen :)
omg i noe exactly wat its like to be bullied every single day nd carmen did not deserve tht those girls got wat they deserved. wat goes around comes around
IM TOTALLY FREAKED OUT NOW MAN!!!!!!!!(i believe..i believe..i believe..i believe)
I believe your story Carmen.
hey..xx Carmen, i don’t blame you for getting back at those stupid discustingly evil girls. I would of done the exact same thing. YOU GO GIRL. And dont worry you dont need to come after me because i believe everything about your story. That is very horrible,about what they did to you and they should really be ashaimed of them selfs shouldnt they. And i would of made you my bestest friend ever because you seem like a very kind-hearted girl and i would of loved for you to be my bffl. Well done carmen winstead for getting back at those stupid girls i HATE them they are just horrible. WELL DONE. Im with you.x
carmen is a very kind-hearted girl and i love her to bits she was so pretty as well. When i die i am going to torture them 5girls like hey did to you carem winstead dont you worry.xxi love you..xx
thats just mest up im on carmens side!
hey..xx Carmen me and my friend’s chloe,hollie and miriam are all on your side,okay.Because you did nothing wrong to hurt them five girls and they pushed the line there and then didnt they.. So me,chloe,hollie and miriam think that you should torture them even more.(Even know they’re dead now.)You should still hurt them,over what they did. They had deffinitely crossed the line.
when me,chloe,hollie and miriam die, we are going to hurt them as much as they hurt you,okay,dont you worry. Me and my friend’s love you carmen winstead and think that you are one of those girls who are special. We think that you should of lived a more happier life than what them girls did to you.
P.S Me,Chloe,Hollie and Miriam thought and still do think that you are a very pretty,young girl who deserved a much happier and longer life. WE ALL LOVE YOU!(me,chloe,hollie and miriam.)XxXx.
Team Carmen (:
Stupid Girls, Who would think that it would be harmless to push a young beautiful, defensless girl down a sewer?
Yeah, A retarded girl.
xoxox (:
Those 5 girls are **** and deserve to die after (KILLING) a person who just moved into indiana i hear alot of bad things happend but this is terrible i hope carmen rests in peace btw i dont really foward most messages but i only sent it to 5 people i trust and know but the same thing here happens to me at school. this one kid choked me for owning him in volley ball :P and this one kid pulled my head back for stepping on his shoes during soccer :P “Its an Imperfect World but its the only one we got.”
omg i’m soooo sorry carmen RIP. wow girl thats just f’d what those bitchy girls did to u and not telling the truth to the cops what dumb asses they deserve what they got. Everytime i get ur forward i send it to 10 friends just like the forward says i truly believe in your story bcuz most girls r bitches im sooooooo sorry for what those evil crule ppl did to u like those messed up students for laughing when those evil bitches pushed u into the sewer.And those kids where in highschool i thought they would b more mature than that what imature jerks. RIP CARMEN WINSTEAD oh yea sweetie i would b ur friend anyday and everyday. Theres many ppl who care about u love ya girly! RIP <3
Those Fake so called friends of Carmen were just jelouse of her.
that is soooooo mean!!! i always try 2 welcum the new kid cuz if that was me i wudnt want that 2 happen!! those girls got what they deserved!!! i luv u carmen
This is crazy!!!!! I wish tht this nvr happend. We all care about you Carmen and we miss you. R.I.P. Carmen. I wish tht you had stayed back where you lived. Most of all I wish those girls nvr did tht to you. If you went to my school I would want to be best friends!!! I love new ppl at my school bc regular ppl get boring. Miss you. R.I.P. and we miss you. :) <3 you
those girls deserved to be dead b’cuz i believe and I’m on Carmen’s side (i believe i believe i believe i believe)
i belive it but you spelled yogurt worng
srry i meant wrong
THATS HORRIBLE WHAT THEY DID TO HER!!! As if Carmen hadnt had enough with them bullying her they just killed her and then to lie about it! Poor Carmen what did she ever do to them i mean nobody deserves to die but it was horrible what they did.
Those girls were soooo mean and wrong to do that to her they should really take resposibility for their actions. I feel bad for Carmen
those b*****s deserved to be killed. they were s***-heads to her and Carmen was a nice person who wanted friends not to die. let those b*****s rest in HELL!!!!!!lol. have a good night Carmen
that is some bull i would of left it alone.. and i would never in my life kill some one i believe this is true carmen i will always be your friend because ppl need friends and those 5 girls will never of never made friends if they were still alive if i have a friend i would try to treat them nice i wouldnt be like those 5 girls i would take care of my friends and be nice to them i would any way……..i love you cARMEN
I just got this as a forward, and this is ****** UP. What kinda girls do this. That is CRUEL. I’m glad those girls died cuz they deserved it. RIP carmen<3 you will be missed!
omg tht wuld be scary to find ur self like her
Oh And I Believe yhu. I Do Believe. Awwww Carmen . I Feel so bad ]: i was bullied too. i hate it. They talked about my dad who is gone forever. D: im so sorry what happened to you Carmen ]: R.I.P
the 5 girls got wat they got an i hope carmen is in heaven cuz she didnt deserve to die
I just got this in a foward message , I didn’t believe it so I googled it but woow this really creeped me out. Pooor Carmen, I never been bullied but I never bully people. Why would you? Its just makes you look mean & such an ugly person. Its good what those 5 girls got! RiP Carmen x3
Immmmmm am sooooo srry tht happened to u….tht was wrong of those 5 girls to do tht to u….i dont understand why people would do something tht cruel…..im very srry tht happened…..i can understand how u feel and other girls do to….cuz they have been bullied and i have toooo… they would call me names and chase me and push me down….im srry very srry
I feel bad for Carmen first off being relocated to a new state new school and leaving all your best friends behind…Then being literally tortured with they’re cruel pranks…I definitely believe this legend is 100% true and I also believe those girls that murdered Carmen pushing her down a sewer deserved what they got…to die and Carmen…I’m on your side definitely
-KittyKat
wow that’s not right ii feel bad for Carmen ii bet she was a very beautiful girl and the onlii reason why those low life girls did that is because they’re insecure about themselves and they were trying to show off but it wasn’t even cool wha theii did how could they look the cop in the eye and lie ? smh welps! there in hell now so they can rot there, as for Carmen she’s probably in a better place =] ily Carmen even tho ii neva met u u seemed like a cool girl and ii would’ve been your friend..
STOP BULLYING <<<
It’s not true you know. I never believed it and I haven’t been pulled down a drain yet.
I mean, It’s a good story but…
i think its really sad..and no one should do that to people,to anyone. people need to be nice!
Oh Poor Carmen! Those bullies are soo mean!
OMG!!! I believe that she was pushed down a sewer 150%! I mean, with her age, what kind of person would just “fall” down a sewer. You would see it, and not go down it… but, those bullies are mean. they deserved to die. If i was her friend, i would stand up for her, and rather me get pushed down a sewer than her, i mean, i bet she was a nice, kind, open hearted girl. But, these bullies have no heart!!!!! Those 5 girls are in Hell where they can rot and they deserve to be there. With carmen, she is in Heaven where she belongs because like I said, i bet she was a kind, open hearted girl.
Wow. Those girls and boys deserve to die! Why would they push a innocent girl down a sewer? When she never did anything :( Poor Carmen.
omygoshh. i feel so sorry for carmen. but those 5 girls deserved it. they shouldnt have been so mean to her. i believe this story 100%
Oh poor Carmen she doesint deserve that, the five girls should deserved that. If I was in her new school I would of been friends with her, and I would of saved her life.
OMG She was soo pretty I cant beleive somone would do that. Those girls are soo mean. Gosh that makes me want to cry!
What did carmen do, I would have saved her life if i was there.
At first I didn’t believe it when I got the Text Message, then the more I thought about it the more scared I got.. I quickly sent it, and felt good. This is truly a scary story… I hope she can finally rest in piece one day, on that day, only believers will be left.
R.I.P. Carmen Winstead
poor carmen!im wiht u they got a god damn right to die R.I.P. carmen oneday you’ll be put to rest properly she didnt deserve it poor carmen
Omg Carmen i am on your side if i went to that school i would have befriended u immidiatley u did not diserve to get bullied they did all of those girls diserve to die not u! how can someone be so cruel???!!!. U had the right to kill them! But i got this fwd and it said send to 20 people or u will get ur neck broken and face pealed off and be in a sewer and u’ll be dead so i sent it to 20 people. but Carmen did not diserve to die!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OMG my friend sent me this text and even tho I sent it I was so freaked out I slept in my parents room, Then my friend sent it to me again and even tho I sent it before I sent it again, I really want to know if this is real or not so I can stop worrying. PLEASE DONT SEND ME FORWORDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
This is so sad. Kids these days are just so mean. I want to know how they could go to sleep knowing that they had killed someone. I’m sorry Carmen!
AM so sorry that they did that to you if i went to your school i wat of ben your friend your best friend your in a bettet place now
Wow, thats horrible. Im so sorry carmen. Carmen didnt deserve to die. She was just a teenage girl going through a hard time. I honestly don’t think those girls deserved to die, because no one deserves to face death as cruecial as that, but I do think they should’ve been severly punished. But we all love carmen… R.I.P.
look she is real me and my friends have researched everything and as long as you believe in her you shouldnt be scared she wont hurt you! My friends and i (me lottie and my two friends chloe and rebecca) all love you and we wish you were here now! bye xx carmen xxx
i belive this story is true but but some people have made diffrent things to it its very sad r.i.p carmen them girls deserves what happened to them xx
Thats just wrong big time! If i was there and saw it, I would have told the police that those 5 little brats killed you! I believe every single word from that story, they deserved to die not you. RIP Carmen.
=o…poor carmen..I feel so bad….she’s the one that played in that movie…
Those gurls deserve 2 die..
Carmen was a inacent gurl…that’s not right..
Those gurls are gunah pay 4 wahh they had done
im so sorry for you carmen . i do believe you , and im not saying this to save my life…. but please realise that people are sorry for you , and everyone do believe you . you have also taken revenge on the people you hate . so please realise that your duties are over and join the father in heaven above . i am sure that the five girls who killed you are suffering in hell . i think it is time you rest in peace .i wish good for your soul and want it to atttain salvation .
for all we know Carmen could have been a bitch -.- anyways yea it was tragic but the 5 girls didn’t need to die … let me explain b4 you hate me its cuz death isn’t the end of all life its only a break from it with every death there’s a rebirth and Carmen isn’t any better then the girls that pushed her down the sewer because she did it to the only way to live a peaceful life is to forgive maybe not forget but at the least not sink their level which Carmen did
I feel sorry for her those girl deserve it for what they did
I think it’s true but I’m just saying that bc I don’t want to die
i feel sorry for carmen im on carmen’s side
poor carmen they deserve ittttttttt those mean girls